573
edits
User talk:Bigstones: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
→wiki restructuring
m (→wiki restructuring: CategoryTree is working again) |
|||
| Line 77: | Line 77: | ||
::: Looking forward to the final version of your "review". Always nice to have a fresh impression of our documentation! | ::: Looking forward to the final version of your "review". Always nice to have a fresh impression of our documentation! | ||
::: [[User:Gijs|Gijs]] ([[User talk:Gijs|talk]]) 19:03, 6 May 2014 (UTC) | ::: [[User:Gijs|Gijs]] ([[User talk:Gijs|talk]]) 19:03, 6 May 2014 (UTC) | ||
:::: I'm really glad and relieved to see these comments, I'd say these ideas are welcome to discussion and that's great. To answer rapidly Gijs: | |||
::::* By categories used like tags I mean that instead that using a particular, deep enough category one prefers to use two categories, unrelated, that combine to make a particular one. Details are where I talk about "orthogonal categories" (the too long part). | |||
::::* With "one category per article" I mean that each article should belong to only one category. I try my best with english, I'll try to clarify that. | |||
::::* I've just read about Extension:CategoryTree [[FlightGear wiki:Village pump#Found_bugs|in Village pump]]! I wondered why there wasn't such a useful tool here. | |||
::::* OK. If people did like I did with the MCX article, I see why it could have lost quality. | |||
:::: My review is pretty much complete, I see already 3 admins/maintainers (or major contributors?) have read it, how many others do you think will be interested? Do you think it's possible to start a collaborative version of this plan and then condense it in a guideline? That is, avoiding the "wiki quality portal" (cit. Johan). | |||
:::: | |||
::::I'll give a read at [[Help:Categories]] and Johan's essay, maybe I can tune my paper towards those to ease discussion (any other document I should consider?). I'll move it to a user page like Johan. | |||
:::: | |||
::::(ps: I've read Raymond's essay a long time ago, much more recently [[How the FlightGear project works]], I'm just fine with that) | |||
::::--[[User:Bigstones|Bigstones]] ([[User talk:Bigstones|talk]]) 20:01, 6 May 2014 (UTC) | |||